Monday, May 16, 2005

Mega Churches: As Much Fun As A Good Old Fashioned Revival, Plus An Espresso Bar

In the early ninetieth century slave trade was not the only thing booming. The love of Jesus was poring through the hearts of white people all backcrossed this country. It was a glorious time that nostalgic Evangelicals and Baptists call "The Second Great Awaking" or SGA. The Second Great Awaking started as a rejection of the predetermination that one finds in Calvinism. It stated that man is responsible, and able, to freely choose to accept Christ or not. This brand of Christianity, that threw logic to the spirit filled dogs, could be seen as a reflection of the optimism that must have been felt in this country at the time. Imagine being so optimistic to think that you could prove God wrong by deciding to accept Jesus when he was sure that you wouldn't! The Second Great Awaking found its beginnings in Utica New York by a lawyer turned preacher named Charles Finny. He was a charismatic who beloved that the holy spirit had the power to make people do some really buzzer things like fall to the ground, shout out non-sensual phrases, and let's not for get everyone’s favorite, a tradition that is still with us today, heal every kind of illness you can think of . They healed everything from the whooping cough to the rheumatism. It was a great time had by all. It was really evident to all Americans that God really did like us best. There was talk of forming a truly Christian republic. People were admonished not be complacent to the evils of slavery. Women's suffrage and workers rights are all associated with the second great revival. By all accounts it was a really wild ride. This great awaking like the first eventually abated and people were no longer receiving spiritual sustenance from the Holy Spirit any more. 

Tuesday, May 10, 2005

Atheism: The hardest decision I never made

Fundamental to the moral supremacy that most evangelicals in this country claim is the belief that they somehow chose to be convinced that Jesus was the son of God. Fundamental to the moral supremacy that most liberals have is that they some how chose to accept John Stewart Mill's On Liberty as an adequate starting point for creating a just society (or at least would have if they bothered to read it). 

Thursday, May 5, 2005

God and Gays

Last week two different groups descended upon Focus On The Family, a conservative Christian college in Colorado Springs, CO, to protest the institution’s founder James Dobson and his rhetoric on gays and lesbians. The first group was a coalition of various different gay rights groups. They were there to protest the Dobson's stated views against gay marriage. The other group represented Westboro Baptist Church famous for their controversial website godhatesfags.com. They were there to protest Dobson's soft approach on the GLBT community. Apparently their belief that gays and lesbians will spend an eternity in hell is not adequate vindication. The major issue of the day surrounding the gay issue is of course gay marriage. It was used as a wedge issue during the 2004 presidential election and 11 states voted to pass a referendum banning same sex coupling. This issue is a strange one and the Christian right seems to have at 3 major objections to gay marriage that I intend to address here. The first is the fact that the bible says that it is very bad for two people of the same sex to lay together. The Christian also right has "secular" reasons why there should be no same sex unions. The first is that marriage is an institution that the state condones so that the state can keep intact the family structure so that the state can grow and prosper. Since two men cannot produce a child it would be silly for the state to allow same sex coupling. The second is an economic type argument that says that married people receive benefits and tax credits when they get married, and the economy could not handle all these gays shacking up and taking advantage of all of them. I am sure that his list is not comprehensive but I would like to address these arguments and show that in each case the Christian Right is inconsistent on each of them.

The belief that the bible condemns homo-sexuality is a well founded one. There are several places in the Bible that clearly state that it is wrong. I think everyone's favorite these days is in Leviticus, but there are several in the New Testament as well. There is nothing wrong with people thinking that it is wrong. What is strange is their refusal to believe that every rule in the bible has been followed the exact same way through out history, or at least it should have. Matthew 5:31-32 states pretty clearly that if a woman gets divorced and marries another man both parties have committed adultery. Given this bit of knowledge, and the divorce rate being what it is these days, I would say that adultery represents a more urgent moral crisis for our God fearing country. I cannot see any reason why the Gay issue is more important to them.

In one of my Philosophy classes last year someone brought up the point that same-sex coupling should not be allowed because it was not in the interest of the state. The state gives certain benefits to married couples to ensure that there are future generations through procreation. Same-sex couples cannot have kids; therefore it would be silly to allow same-sex couples married status. This argument fails from the start because there are so many examples where the state allows the union of people that will never procreate. It is not as if we are telling two 85 year olds that they cannot get married because they won't be able to procreate. Nor would we tell some body that was in a car accident that made it impossible for them to have children that they could not get married. So to say it is just matter of procreation seems rather silly.

The final secular argument that I will address is by far the cruelest. It states that if allow the same benefits to same sex couples that we do for heterosexual opinions that businesses and governmental agencies would not be able to handle the finical burdens. I don't want to get hung up on if this is true or not. Even if it is true it is not sufficient justification to deny a group of people the rights that we grant to another group. It would be like saying that slavery should be kept legal because otherwise the poor plantation owners will go broke.

Tuesday, May 3, 2005

Fixation on Belief

Listening to Christian talk radio is always a good way to get me yelling at the radio while driving to work. It's interesting how they scoff, quite seriously, at beliefs that I am most certain are true. I heard a two hour documentary on evolution that claimed that creationism was still the more tenable theory of the two. I am always hearing them mindlessly support George W Bush in every thing he does including the tax cuts; I'm not sure what the biblical basis is for that particular fiscal policy. After hearing about an hour of this, one would think that any idiot could easily show them that God does not exist, and that they have wasted their lives. However, as anyone that has really tried de-evangelize a Christian will tell you, it is very difficult indeed. It seems that they will not listen to reason, ignore any points you make that my jeopardize their belief, and even if you do cause any doubts in their minds in the time that you talk to them, they most certainly forget all about them at the next Bible study. This can be frustrating, but what is even more infuriating is that Christians are often times equally; if not more, frustrated by the fact that you cannot see the obvious truth of Christ’s teachings and resurrection. This frustration is similar to that of a conservative and a liberal debating political ideology or somebody that believes aliens are really just humans from the future debating someone who believes that they are from another planet.

Charles Sanders Pierce, an American philosopher, had a very insightful view on belief. In his paper "Fixation of Belief" Pierce posited that doubt and belief were in fact psychological states that people experienced. Doubt, Pierce explained, is a very uncomfortable state which humans naturally try to avoid. The only remedy for doubt is some kind of belief. Belief, in Pierces view, is a "calm satisfactory state" which most to not wish to avoid. On the contrary, Pierce believed that we cling tenaciously to our own belief so as not to experience that depressing and hopeless moment of doubt. If we should find ourselves in a state of doubt we begin the search for an opinion that we can accept. Therefore, it is not truth that we are looking for when we are in a state of doubt, and beliefs can satisfy doubt whether or not they are true. This means that one could alleviate their doubts about the war in Iraq by believing that Jesus told Bush that it was a good idea.

What most concern me about all this are the implications of Piece’s ideas. It calls into question everything that we believe. Take the Christian who does not believe in evolution. Now say this Christian is to meet a biologist who specializes in evolution, or DNA sequencing, or something to that effect. We can imagine the conversation, the evidence the biologist would give, the scripture passages the Christian would quote. In the end which outcome seems more plausible? Does the Christian go and renounce his faith, leave his church, and get on with his life? Or does he go share his concerns with his pastor who comforts him with promises of redemption, and reminds them of Satan's tricks to deceive the faithful? He may even receive a lecture on the implausibility of natural selection. Or imagine the anti-globalization activist who gets into an argument with an economist who can give good reasons and examples why globalization is inevitable and desirable. The hippy isn't going to renounce pot or change his or her views because of a few facts or statistics the point is that we are largely unable to change our beliefs even in the face of contradicting evidence. It is not that people never change their minds, but it is usually after a long period of consideration and discourse, and that just doesn't happen in the public arena anymore.

If this is the case, where does that leave politics? Where does that leave popular discourse? Where does that leave journalism? If beliefs are so far removed from reality that in many cases reality plays no role whatsoever in forming them, then what business do I have telling someone believing in UFOs that they are crazy? It is my business because believing in UFOs is crazy, as is voting republican and believing in the resurrection of Christ.

Monday, May 2, 2005

Feminist Ethics and Christanity

I would like to start with this with an idea that I had a couple weeks ago and develop it from there. My thesis is that the teachings of Jesus Christ coinside more with the feminist ethics of care than with more traditional universalist ethics of the deontological type(deontological means "duty" based in this case) . It is impossible to explain the many different forms and complexities both of these ethical systems embody. Roughly speaking traditional ethics is concerned with what is just for all. In this case the ideal is that moral decisions are made in a very dry and detached state of mind. This ideal of detachment comes from the enlightenment ideal of reason being the exclusive to discover truth. The difficulty with this view is that we sometimes have trouble believeing that the kind things that people do, or the just things that people accomplish for the world communitny are done because of an objective moral geometrician in inside there heads. There is a real moral feeling involved in many cases that most would not disreguard. Feminists ethics asks the question: What kinds of things have been left out of traditional ethics due to women being excluded from the moral discourse. The work of Carol Gilligan is the peace of feminis ethics that I wish to focus on. Carol Gilligan was a psychologist who conducted studies that showed that women did not make moral decisions on the basis of things like fairness or universal justice. Rather women make moral decisions with relations, and what is expected of someone in the context of intimate relationships. Gilligan coined the term the "ethics of care" to address these very real ethical feelings that traditional ethics had trouble accounting for. The ethics of care has recieved both praise and criticism from feminist ethics as a whole. Indeed, the ethics of care is only one part of feminist ethics as a whole. A great resource for feminist ethis is "Explorations In Feminist Ethics: Theory and Practice" edited by Eve Browning Cole and Susan Coulrap-McQuin. But what would Jesus tell us to do? I think it's clear that time and time again we are reminded in the bible to love each other. In countless examples in the bible Jesus asks us to love one another not to be just to one another. It could be argued that by loving everyone we are being just, but I think that misses the mark. When we think justice we think guilty or innocent, sin or not sin(?). These notions are never supposed to enter our minds when we think of love. At least not innitially. The examples of Jesus talking about love are numerous and I do not need to bore you with them. The point is that Jesus called christians to love and not to be arbiters of justice. They don't have to worry about things that are not in our immediate sphere of relations. This sounds cruel and ethno-centric to any self respecting american liberal and maybe it is. However, the idea was not change the world through good acts the goal was save the world through the blood of Christ. If what I have said is true or remotely valid I believe the implications of this become very interesting. The first is that Christians have no right to use there religion has a reason to extend justice through out the world. THere are plenty of people who need love right next door. This is true for both liberals and conservatives. War in Iraq? Not for Jesus's sake. Supporting amnesty international in the name of Christ? Not the best way to go I think. The point here is not that Christians should not engage in public discourse should or not should not support the war in Iraq it is merely that their faith should not play quite so large of a role in their decision making. It is not our place to dispence with the wicked it is our job to love. In closing I should say that I am not a Christian. I am not even remotely convinced so it facinates me that people are. The same kind of facination some people derive from talking to some one with schizophrenia. I am always amazed at the conclusions people draw from their religion.

Sunday, May 1, 2005

The Guilt Has Finally Over Taken Me.

To continue existing in this world without sharing the wealth of knowledge that God has blessed (or cursed) me with seems to me to be more reprehensible than letting people die when the liberal elites have convinced them they would rather die when they are hooked to life support. If I may digress for a moment-It's not in God's plan people! God intended human technology to someday reach a point where we could extend human life past the point of even having a functional brain which as any real doctor will tell is different from the soul which is located closer to the stomach. The only time that someone should be removed from life support is when they cannot pay for it. Which is kind of wisdom governor George W Bush showed when he signed a bill into law allowing hospitals to pull the plug on people whose family could not afford to pay for life support. This is not what I came here to say. I was getting to the part about me being a vessel. Yes, I am not a god, or deity, or god. I am but a vessel who has been given certain truths that I feel obligated to give to the you the stupid masses or mass if it is just one of you. I suppose that as long as I am on the subject I would like to address the right to die issue this was a recent unpublished letter to the editor that remains unpublished in any real or valid forum. This letter was sent on 3/22/05. It appears that the Schiavo Case is another perfect opportunity for the American public to showed world just how schizophrenic they are. On one side, we have soldiers and civilians dying in Iraq for this sacred thing that we like to call Freedom. Freedom, as any God-fearing American will tell you, is worth dying for. In this case, Freedom trumps the sanctity of life. On the other side, we have a women who had expressed to her husband that if she ever became brain dead or needed life support to survive,she would rather be let go. A free decision made in a freedom-loving society. In this case, the sanctity of life trumps Freedom. The American public, with all their common sense,have decreed that her freedom should be nullified inorder to protect the sanctity of life; conversely, the soldier must die to protect the sanctity of Freedom.And these contradictory ideals flow effortlessly fromtheir psyche. A more naïve, pre-election version of myself would not have believed Americans to be the cause of such embarrassment.