Tuesday, May 10, 2005

Atheism: The hardest decision I never made

Fundamental to the moral supremacy that most evangelicals in this country claim is the belief that they somehow chose to be convinced that Jesus was the son of God. Fundamental to the moral supremacy that most liberals have is that they some how chose to accept John Stewart Mill's On Liberty as an adequate starting point for creating a just society (or at least would have if they bothered to read it). 


Believing that belief is a choice has allowed Evangelicals, and intelligent people, to condemn others for not sharing their beliefs. This is because choice demands accountability. A person would be condemned for bringing red wine to a salmon dinner if there was also a nice white wine at the liquor store as well. If, on the other hand, there were only bottles of merlot, all would be forgiven. The same is true of belief; if belief is not a choice than it is silly, if not reprehensible, to hold some one accountable for those beliefs. It is not surprise that people hold that their beliefs are chosen. Indeed, it fits very nicely with the free American ideal of autonomy and freedom chosen by free people in a free society, where only freedom can prevail. It gives us the impression that we really own our beliefs. Bush would love the idea, as it fits so nicely with his ownership utopia. I think that there are some problems with believing that belief is a choice. Holding that belief is a choice seems to invalidate those beliefs. If someone that I was debating said they arrived at their belief by sheer choice, I would not be inclined to continue the debate; choice is a hard argument to attack.

I have recently become convinced that belief is not something that is chosen. There is one experiment that I tried that convinced of me of this. I tried to believe that 2+2=7. After about three hours of this I was convinced that not only did I have to find something better to do with my time, but that there was no way for me to decide what I could believe. However when I tried to convince others of this I found it to be very hard sell. After all, 2+2 is one thing, but belief in God that is a whole other set of criteria. I want to be very clear here. I am not talking about how people come to believe things. I am suggesting that how ever it happens belief is a not choice. 

As I tested this idea out with more people I found that the people that had the most difficulty accepting that belief is not a choice were the Christians. It seemed outrageous to them that their belief in the divine Christ was some how just happened, that they had absolutely no agency in their salvation. In a previous blog I talked about the Second Great Revival. I explained, in a less than laconic manner that, that the Second Great Revival had a lot to do with the rejection of Calvinism. Liberals that had trouble believing that belief was not a choice often seemed to cling to their "correct" beliefs like an accolade that they had given themselves. As if by some assiduous effort they had attained the correct moral belief. I would like to know how other culture feel about this notion of choice and belief, because I a have a suspicion that it is much more ubiquitous in the US.

No comments: