Monday, May 2, 2005

Feminist Ethics and Christanity

I would like to start with this with an idea that I had a couple weeks ago and develop it from there. My thesis is that the teachings of Jesus Christ coinside more with the feminist ethics of care than with more traditional universalist ethics of the deontological type(deontological means "duty" based in this case) . It is impossible to explain the many different forms and complexities both of these ethical systems embody. Roughly speaking traditional ethics is concerned with what is just for all. In this case the ideal is that moral decisions are made in a very dry and detached state of mind. This ideal of detachment comes from the enlightenment ideal of reason being the exclusive to discover truth. The difficulty with this view is that we sometimes have trouble believeing that the kind things that people do, or the just things that people accomplish for the world communitny are done because of an objective moral geometrician in inside there heads. There is a real moral feeling involved in many cases that most would not disreguard. Feminists ethics asks the question: What kinds of things have been left out of traditional ethics due to women being excluded from the moral discourse. The work of Carol Gilligan is the peace of feminis ethics that I wish to focus on. Carol Gilligan was a psychologist who conducted studies that showed that women did not make moral decisions on the basis of things like fairness or universal justice. Rather women make moral decisions with relations, and what is expected of someone in the context of intimate relationships. Gilligan coined the term the "ethics of care" to address these very real ethical feelings that traditional ethics had trouble accounting for. The ethics of care has recieved both praise and criticism from feminist ethics as a whole. Indeed, the ethics of care is only one part of feminist ethics as a whole. A great resource for feminist ethis is "Explorations In Feminist Ethics: Theory and Practice" edited by Eve Browning Cole and Susan Coulrap-McQuin. But what would Jesus tell us to do? I think it's clear that time and time again we are reminded in the bible to love each other. In countless examples in the bible Jesus asks us to love one another not to be just to one another. It could be argued that by loving everyone we are being just, but I think that misses the mark. When we think justice we think guilty or innocent, sin or not sin(?). These notions are never supposed to enter our minds when we think of love. At least not innitially. The examples of Jesus talking about love are numerous and I do not need to bore you with them. The point is that Jesus called christians to love and not to be arbiters of justice. They don't have to worry about things that are not in our immediate sphere of relations. This sounds cruel and ethno-centric to any self respecting american liberal and maybe it is. However, the idea was not change the world through good acts the goal was save the world through the blood of Christ. If what I have said is true or remotely valid I believe the implications of this become very interesting. The first is that Christians have no right to use there religion has a reason to extend justice through out the world. THere are plenty of people who need love right next door. This is true for both liberals and conservatives. War in Iraq? Not for Jesus's sake. Supporting amnesty international in the name of Christ? Not the best way to go I think. The point here is not that Christians should not engage in public discourse should or not should not support the war in Iraq it is merely that their faith should not play quite so large of a role in their decision making. It is not our place to dispence with the wicked it is our job to love. In closing I should say that I am not a Christian. I am not even remotely convinced so it facinates me that people are. The same kind of facination some people derive from talking to some one with schizophrenia. I am always amazed at the conclusions people draw from their religion.

No comments: