Tuesday, May 3, 2005

Fixation on Belief

Listening to Christian talk radio is always a good way to get me yelling at the radio while driving to work. It's interesting how they scoff, quite seriously, at beliefs that I am most certain are true. I heard a two hour documentary on evolution that claimed that creationism was still the more tenable theory of the two. I am always hearing them mindlessly support George W Bush in every thing he does including the tax cuts; I'm not sure what the biblical basis is for that particular fiscal policy. After hearing about an hour of this, one would think that any idiot could easily show them that God does not exist, and that they have wasted their lives. However, as anyone that has really tried de-evangelize a Christian will tell you, it is very difficult indeed. It seems that they will not listen to reason, ignore any points you make that my jeopardize their belief, and even if you do cause any doubts in their minds in the time that you talk to them, they most certainly forget all about them at the next Bible study. This can be frustrating, but what is even more infuriating is that Christians are often times equally; if not more, frustrated by the fact that you cannot see the obvious truth of Christ’s teachings and resurrection. This frustration is similar to that of a conservative and a liberal debating political ideology or somebody that believes aliens are really just humans from the future debating someone who believes that they are from another planet.

Charles Sanders Pierce, an American philosopher, had a very insightful view on belief. In his paper "Fixation of Belief" Pierce posited that doubt and belief were in fact psychological states that people experienced. Doubt, Pierce explained, is a very uncomfortable state which humans naturally try to avoid. The only remedy for doubt is some kind of belief. Belief, in Pierces view, is a "calm satisfactory state" which most to not wish to avoid. On the contrary, Pierce believed that we cling tenaciously to our own belief so as not to experience that depressing and hopeless moment of doubt. If we should find ourselves in a state of doubt we begin the search for an opinion that we can accept. Therefore, it is not truth that we are looking for when we are in a state of doubt, and beliefs can satisfy doubt whether or not they are true. This means that one could alleviate their doubts about the war in Iraq by believing that Jesus told Bush that it was a good idea.

What most concern me about all this are the implications of Piece’s ideas. It calls into question everything that we believe. Take the Christian who does not believe in evolution. Now say this Christian is to meet a biologist who specializes in evolution, or DNA sequencing, or something to that effect. We can imagine the conversation, the evidence the biologist would give, the scripture passages the Christian would quote. In the end which outcome seems more plausible? Does the Christian go and renounce his faith, leave his church, and get on with his life? Or does he go share his concerns with his pastor who comforts him with promises of redemption, and reminds them of Satan's tricks to deceive the faithful? He may even receive a lecture on the implausibility of natural selection. Or imagine the anti-globalization activist who gets into an argument with an economist who can give good reasons and examples why globalization is inevitable and desirable. The hippy isn't going to renounce pot or change his or her views because of a few facts or statistics the point is that we are largely unable to change our beliefs even in the face of contradicting evidence. It is not that people never change their minds, but it is usually after a long period of consideration and discourse, and that just doesn't happen in the public arena anymore.

If this is the case, where does that leave politics? Where does that leave popular discourse? Where does that leave journalism? If beliefs are so far removed from reality that in many cases reality plays no role whatsoever in forming them, then what business do I have telling someone believing in UFOs that they are crazy? It is my business because believing in UFOs is crazy, as is voting republican and believing in the resurrection of Christ.

No comments: