Thursday, May 5, 2005

God and Gays

Last week two different groups descended upon Focus On The Family, a conservative Christian college in Colorado Springs, CO, to protest the institution’s founder James Dobson and his rhetoric on gays and lesbians. The first group was a coalition of various different gay rights groups. They were there to protest the Dobson's stated views against gay marriage. The other group represented Westboro Baptist Church famous for their controversial website godhatesfags.com. They were there to protest Dobson's soft approach on the GLBT community. Apparently their belief that gays and lesbians will spend an eternity in hell is not adequate vindication. The major issue of the day surrounding the gay issue is of course gay marriage. It was used as a wedge issue during the 2004 presidential election and 11 states voted to pass a referendum banning same sex coupling. This issue is a strange one and the Christian right seems to have at 3 major objections to gay marriage that I intend to address here. The first is the fact that the bible says that it is very bad for two people of the same sex to lay together. The Christian also right has "secular" reasons why there should be no same sex unions. The first is that marriage is an institution that the state condones so that the state can keep intact the family structure so that the state can grow and prosper. Since two men cannot produce a child it would be silly for the state to allow same sex coupling. The second is an economic type argument that says that married people receive benefits and tax credits when they get married, and the economy could not handle all these gays shacking up and taking advantage of all of them. I am sure that his list is not comprehensive but I would like to address these arguments and show that in each case the Christian Right is inconsistent on each of them.

The belief that the bible condemns homo-sexuality is a well founded one. There are several places in the Bible that clearly state that it is wrong. I think everyone's favorite these days is in Leviticus, but there are several in the New Testament as well. There is nothing wrong with people thinking that it is wrong. What is strange is their refusal to believe that every rule in the bible has been followed the exact same way through out history, or at least it should have. Matthew 5:31-32 states pretty clearly that if a woman gets divorced and marries another man both parties have committed adultery. Given this bit of knowledge, and the divorce rate being what it is these days, I would say that adultery represents a more urgent moral crisis for our God fearing country. I cannot see any reason why the Gay issue is more important to them.

In one of my Philosophy classes last year someone brought up the point that same-sex coupling should not be allowed because it was not in the interest of the state. The state gives certain benefits to married couples to ensure that there are future generations through procreation. Same-sex couples cannot have kids; therefore it would be silly to allow same-sex couples married status. This argument fails from the start because there are so many examples where the state allows the union of people that will never procreate. It is not as if we are telling two 85 year olds that they cannot get married because they won't be able to procreate. Nor would we tell some body that was in a car accident that made it impossible for them to have children that they could not get married. So to say it is just matter of procreation seems rather silly.

The final secular argument that I will address is by far the cruelest. It states that if allow the same benefits to same sex couples that we do for heterosexual opinions that businesses and governmental agencies would not be able to handle the finical burdens. I don't want to get hung up on if this is true or not. Even if it is true it is not sufficient justification to deny a group of people the rights that we grant to another group. It would be like saying that slavery should be kept legal because otherwise the poor plantation owners will go broke.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Hey Peter- This is Tom from up in Duluth. Liz directed me to your blahg and I couldn't help responding. One point to add on to the gays and God argument is that Massachusets, one of two(?) states that allows gay marriage has one of, if not the lowest divorce rate in the U.S. It's a decent reply to the argument that allowing gays to marry will ruin marriage for us straight folk. I think I saw a list of the states that have the highest divorce rates and at the top of the list was one of the 11 that passed the a no-gays-allowed law.
Anyhow...I hope we cross paths soon.
-Tom
PS: I heard a kick ass cover of Bowies' "Lets Dance" I want to share with you.